Skip to content

Custom Homes Gary

For the home shopper that wants a truly one-of-a-kind home, we’re proud to showcase some of the best custom homes in Gary, IN. When you have complete creative control over your new home, you’re sure to end up with something far from cookie cutter. You can customize everything from the floor plan to the exterior elevation to the standard design options including flooring, fixtures, cabinetry and more. has 1 new home builders creating custom homes in Gary, IN. With this many options, you’ll want to take your time finding the builder that’s right for your custom home. With custom homes being built in over 2 new home communities, you can still enjoy the wonderful amenities and benefits of being located in a close knit neighborhood. Prices on custom homes in Gary start in the $409900, and from there the possibilities are endless. Bedroom count? Bathroom count? That’s all up to you when you start designing your new custom home!




25 mi

Exact Location

Cancel Update




Cancel Update

Beds & Baths


Cancel Update


School Districts

    Cancel Update


    Home Type
    Home Status
    Special Offers
    Living Areas
    Master Bedroom

    Cancel Update

    164 Homes

    Madison (9761 Tall Grass Trail)

    Madison - The Preserves: Saint John, Indiana - Sublime Homes

    Available Now

    from $499,900

    The Preserves

    • 3 Br
    • 2.5 Ba
    • 3 Gr
    • 2,575 sq. ft.

    Saint John, IN 46373


    Colette (8956 Parrish Ave)

    Colette - Rose Garden: Saint John, Indiana - Sublime Homes

    Available Now

    from $699,900

    Rose Garden

    • 4 Br
    • 3.5 Ba
    • 3 Gr
    • 4,300 sq. ft.

    Saint John, IN 46373


    Other Homes for Sale

    2401 Nottingham Drive

    2401 Nottingham Drive, Valparaiso, Indiana

    Valparaiso, IN 46383


    From $484,900

      5 Br 4 Ba 3,892 sq. ft.

    11226 Putnam Drive

    11226 Putnam Drive, Crown Point, Indiana

    Crown Point, IN 46307


    From $162,894

      3 Br 3 Ba 1,596 sq. ft.

    18418 Peggy Sue Drive

    18418 Peggy Sue Drive, Lowell, Indiana

    Lowell, IN 46356


    From $253,950

      3 Br 2 Ba 1,795 sq. ft.

    2015 Terreno Drive

    2015 Terreno Drive, Chesterton, Indiana

    Chesterton, IN 46304


    From $399,900

      5 Br 2 Ba 2,715 sq. ft.

    5733 West 172nd Avenue

    5733 West 172nd Avenue, Lowell, Indiana

    Lowell, IN 46356


    From $269,900

      3 Br 2 Ba 1,875 sq. ft.

    2002 Emmett Court

    2002 Emmett Court, Valparaiso, Indiana

    Valparaiso, IN 46385


    From $699,500

      5 Br 4 Ba 7,050 sq. ft.

    9772 Tulip Lane

    9772 Tulip Lane, Schererville, Indiana

    Schererville, IN 46375


    From $424,800

      4 Br 3 Ba 2,600 sq. ft.

    10820-Lot 32 North 555 East

    10820-Lot 32 North 555 East, Demotte, Indiana

    Demotte, IN 46310


    From $239,900

      4 Br 3 Ba 2,575 sq. ft.

    Top New Home Cities in Gary

    City Communities Average New Home Price
    Saint John 1 $341,917

    Popular Searches Near Gary, IN