New Construction Homes in Shelter Island

You won’t believe the selection of new construction floor plans in Shelter Island, NY. Not only, do they come in different sizes and price points, but their varying amenities make it easy to find a home that just right for you. Discover open floor plans, first-story master bedrooms, three-car garages and more!

Over 6 homebuilders have together in the Shelter Island, NY to produce some 26 new construction floor plans. Whether your budget is geared towards $415,000 or $6,500,000, it’s all available in Shelter Island.

And don’t forget to use our filtering tools to help narrow down the floor plan that’s right for you. Choose from homes as small as 731 square feet and as large as 3,855 square feet with 1 to 5 Bedrooms and 2 to 5.

Distance

Radius

Exact

25 mi

Exact Location

Cancel Update

Price

Price


to


Cancel Update

Beds & Baths

Bedrooms
Bathrooms

Cancel Update

Schools

School Districts

    Cancel Update

    More

    Home Type
    Home Status
    Special Offers
    Garages
    Living Areas
    Stories/Floors
    Master Bedroom
    Amenities




    Cancel Update



    Quick Move-In Hot Deals Model Homes Ready to Build

    87 Homes

    Other Homes for Sale

    13 Brander Pky

    13 Brander Pky, Shelter Island, New York

    Shelter Island, NY 11964

    Map

    From $1,950,000

      Studio 0 Ba

    54 S Lee Ave

    54 S Lee Ave, Southampton, New York

    Southampton, NY 11968

    Map

    From $4,895,000

      Studio 0 Ba

    N/C Alvahs Ln

    N/C Alvahs Ln, Cutchogue, New York

    Cutchogue, NY 11935

    Map

    From $779,990

      Studio 0 Ba

    120 Pelletreau St

    120 Pelletreau St, Southampton, New York

    Southampton, NY 11968

    Map

    From $3,850,000

      Studio 0 Ba

    29 Margaret Drive

    29 Margaret Drive, Sag Harbor, New York

    Sag Harbor, NY 11963

    Map

    From $3,195,000

      Studio 0 Ba

    Advertisement

    134 Montauk Hwy

    134 Montauk Hwy, Westhampton, New York

    Westhampton, NY 11977

    Map

    From $1,149,000

      Studio 0 Ba

    28 Parkway Drive

    28 Parkway Drive, Sag Harbor, New York

    Sag Harbor, NY 11963

    Map

    From $2,095,000

      Studio 0 Ba

    31 Tyler Drive

    31 Tyler Drive, Riverhead, New York

    Riverhead, NY 11901

    Map

    From $679,000

      Studio 0 Ba

    101 Ellen St

    101 Ellen St, Riverhead, New York

    Riverhead, NY 11901

    Map

    From $459,000

      Studio 0 Ba

    21 Buell Lane Extension

    21  Buell Lane Extension, East Hampton, New York

    East Hampton, NY 11937

    Map

    From $5,650,000

      Studio 0 Ba
    \