- New homes
- Shea Homes
- Reviews
Shea Homes Reviews
saved to favorites!
To see all the homes you’ve saved, visit the My Favorites section of your account.
What Real Homeowners Say About Shea Homes
With an average rating of 4.3 stars, Shea Homes is known for building quality new construction homes. Homebuyers rate their experience based on factors such as floor plans, affordable upgrades, quality craftsmanship, and customer service throughout the homebuilding process. We've collected feedback from 2170 verified homebuyers to give you an honest look at what it's like to build a new home with Shea Homes. Read their unedited reviews, feedback, and complaints to help you decide if Shea Homes is the right builder for your new home.
Customer Reviews
Rocky at first, but worth the wait
- Anonymous
- Verified Homebuyer
- October 01, 2025
- Encinitas, CA
Despite a nearly 4 year long process to move up on the "list" with a less-than-transparent home buying experience, I was finally fortunate enough to be "picked" to purchase a home. I purchased in 9/2024 and closed in 7/2025, which is the exact amount of time that Shea projected. Once in, the home is beautiful and exceeds my expectations which is quite hard to do! It looks alot bigger inside with the walls up rather than framed. There were several issues that I found (despite 4 or 5 sign-offs by Shea and the City) like the ducts not working with the thermostat and an overhead light being ...
Total Score 5
Quality 5
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 5
Thrilled With Our New Home and the Builder’s Team
- Christa J.
- Verified Homebuyer
- September 30, 2025
- Peoria, AZ
Our experience with this builder has been excellent from start to finish. From the initial purchase through the final move-in, every step of the process was clear and well-organized. The builder’s team was responsive, followed through on their promises, and made us feel supported the entire way. The quality of our new home is outstanding—the craftsmanship, attention to detail, and overall value exceeded our expectations. We truly feel confident that we made the right choice, and we would recommend this builder to anyone looking for a trustworthy, reliable, and high-quality home buying ...
Total Score 5
Quality 5
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 5
Best home building experience.
- Kurt C.
- Verified Homebuyer
- September 23, 2025
- Rio Verde, AZ
This is the third home my wife and I have had built. This has been by far the best experience we have had. The Shea team was excellent throughout the entire process. We could not be happier.
Total Score 5
Quality 5
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 5
Shea Home = Dream Home
- Jennifer B.
- Verified Homebuyer
- September 16, 2025
- San Tan Valley, AZ
The whole home buying process with Shea Homes was so smooth..Bailey and her crew addressed all issues before closing. And I received great customer service from both Bailey and Hanna along the way. They have been a pleasure to work with. Shea Homes is top notch. I am now living in my dream home.
Total Score 5
Quality 5
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 5
Shea Homes: Room for Improvement
- Stephanie B.
- Verified Homebuyer
- September 16, 2025
- San Tan Valley, AZ
My experience with Shea Homes was okay overall, but I was disappointed with parts of the process. Their lender offered me an interest rate much higher than the market despite my strong credit, and when I chose another lender, I lost the promised closing cost coverage. I was also told inspection issues would be resolved before closing, but they weren’t though paperwork was signed as if they had been. The home is nice, but the process could have been far more transparent and customer-focused.
Shea Homes responded:
We are grateful for your feedback. Your Warranty Specialist will be following up with you regarding any outstanding items. Also, we appreciate you taking the time to reflect on your experience with Shea Mortgage, we’re committed to learning from it and enhancing the experience for future homeowners. We respect your decision to explore other financing options, and it’s great to hear that you were able to secure a rate that worked better for you. ...
Total Score 3
Quality 4
Trustworthiness 3
Responsiveness 1
New home in Paso Robles Nevina
- Douglas M.
- Verified Homebuyer
- September 09, 2025
- Paso Robles, CA
Love our house. Excellent quality in workmanship. Whenever anything issues quite right they are on it immensely. Amos is our warranty person and he is exceptional. It’s been a great experience.
Total Score 5
Quality 5
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 5
Shea Flats Fox Point Farms
- Don K.
- Verified Homebuyer
- September 02, 2025
- Encinitas, CA
Second Shea home purchased. Both Shea homes I purchased are built with quality. Any issues are promptly addressed.
Total Score 4
Quality 4
Trustworthiness 4
Responsiveness 4
Very pleased with my Fox Point Farms purchase.
- Pamela O.
- Verified Homebuyer
- September 02, 2025
- Encinitas, CA
Overall, the purchase of our condo at Fox Point Farms has been great. Customer Service has been excellent! Victor is great! He responds right away, and repairs are addressed efficiently in good quality.
Total Score 5
Quality 4
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 5
Shea
- Beverly C.
- Verified Homebuyer
- August 26, 2025
- Manvel, TX
Construction manager was great, I truly appreciate his expertise, attention to detail and professionalism. Sales representative was always very responsive, knowledgeable and helpful. Enjoyed working with them both.
Total Score 5
Quality 4
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 5
Good not great
- Ted M.
- Verified Homebuyer
- August 25, 2025
- Marina, CA
Good all around. Would recommend.
Total Score 4
Quality 4
Trustworthiness 4
Responsiveness 4
Great experience with Shea Homes!
- Anonymous
- Verified Homebuyer
- August 25, 2025
- Irvine, CA
We’ve had a great experience with Shea Homes so far. The house itself has been very comfortable to live in, and the overall quality has been excellent. The sales office has been wonderful—professional, attentive, and always providing timely updates and detailed information throughout the process. The on-site inspection team was thorough and helpful during the walkthrough, and the customer service team has also been responsive and supportive. Overall, we’re very happy with our home and with the Shea Homes team. Thank you for making the process smooth and reassuring!
Total Score 5
Quality 5
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 5
Plenty of “misunderstandings”.
- Lori B.
- Verified Homebuyer
- August 20, 2025
- Las Vegas, NV
All charges were not disclosed up front (SID). Didn’t find out about it until signing contract. I was told certain things were included in the HOA which were not. The solar company that I had to sign a contract with filed Chapter 11 Bankruptcy, leaving me in limbo. There were overcharges on documents sent to the loan company. Still waiting to hear back from the HOA management regarding a correction on my account. I will say Frankie went to bat for me regarding building issues. I truly appreciate his willingness to help and make things right for me. Mike has also been great answering any ...
Shea Homes responded:
Hi Lori,
Thank you for sharing your experience. Our mortgage team has previously reviewed with you your loan documents and answered your questions. Please reach out again if you have any additional questions. Your additional comments have been shared with our team.
Total Score 1
Quality 5
Trustworthiness 2
Responsiveness 2
Overall, Shea was great to work with and they build a quality home
- Rodger L.
- Verified Homebuyer
- August 14, 2025
- San Tan Valley, AZ
This was our second build in Encanterra with Shea. Everyone we dealt with was friendly and professional. Susan at the design center was very helpful and got us through the process of selecting our finishes quickly. We did spend quite a bit of time before our meeting with her, selecting a lot ahead so our time with her was more efficient. Antonio and Mike, our site managers, were always eager to meet and address any concerns early on.
Total Score 4
Quality 4
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 5
Best quality and service
- Chun-wei C.
- Verified Homebuyer
- August 12, 2025
- Peoria, AZ
Everything about the house was built as expected, just like what we saw in the design house. Even though there were minor flaws, Shea’s warranty service was excellent
Total Score 5
Quality 5
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 5
Great experience from start to move in.. and after!
- Ashley M.
- Verified Homebuyer
- August 10, 2025
- Encinitas, CA
The Shea team was incredibly helpful, responsive and amazing during the home buying process. Everything was effortless and has been great even past my move in date (thanks Victor!). I can’t say enough wonderful things about Micah and Spencer who were with me every step of the way. They are an amazing duo and represent Shea with honesty, integrity and great work. Thank you!!
Total Score 5
Quality 5
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 5
Di
- Anonymous
- Verified Homebuyer
- August 06, 2025
- Chula Vista, CA
Great experience with shea homes. Their sales team and warranty is unbeatable, we got the exterior and lot that we preferred. The only issue that we found out is the noise isolation is not properly took care of. Same washer and dryer, but the noise is soooo loud! I feel the entire house can here, but I feel the distances and location almost the same in my previous house, I did not hear that much, that's why I deduct the two points from the quality of workmanship and materials.
Total Score 5
Quality 3
Trustworthiness 4
Responsiveness 5
Customer Review after 2 months
- David B.
- Verified Homebuyer
- August 06, 2025
- Marina, CA
The overall homebuying experience was long and a little convoluted, which may have been in part due to the development being new and things still being worked out. An example is that I was told that I would have a backyard sprinkler station installed for me to use while looking at the model homes, but then told after I started the buying process that it was not part of the offering. I was also not too impressed with the Shea Mortgage folks and the amount of paperwork I had to continually update and resubmit, seemed very duplicative and time consuming. For a track home, the quality is ...
Shea Homes responded:
Hi David- We appreciate you taking the time to share your feedback. Your comments have been shared with our team and our Warranty Manager, Adam has reached out to you,
Total Score 3
Quality 4
Trustworthiness 4
Responsiveness 5
Love the new house in Bickford Ranch
- Paul B.
- Verified Homebuyer
- August 06, 2025
- Lincoln, CA
Trilogy at Bickford ranch has a great location on top of a hill. You get the feeling you are out in the country surrounded by open areas. We have all the amenities within a few miles. Come and look for yourself. The people are great.
Total Score 5
Quality 5
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 5
Overall, satisfied with our move to Trilogy at Lake Frederick
- Gregg M.
- Verified Homebuyer
- August 06, 2025
- Front Royal, VA
Overall, our experience has been fairly positive, especially regarding the responsiveness with issues with our home after we moved in.
Total Score 4
Quality 3
Trustworthiness 4
Responsiveness 5
Cant build to minimum standards even for $1 Million dollars
- Anonymous
- Verified Homebuyer
- August 03, 2025
- San Tan Valley, AZ
Cant build a home to minimum standards no matter the price point apparently, constant lies and broken promises. Just point the finger on their sub par subcontractors (and dont take the blame for not paying to get quality people) The executives for these home builders deserve jail time honestly.
Shea Homes responded:
We truly appreciate your feedback and will be sure to share it with our team.
Total Score 1
Quality 1
Trustworthiness 1
Responsiveness 2
Nothing good to say about Shea Homes. Still dealing with a fraudulent Solar lease we were forced into by Shea and multiple structural issues that are not being addressed.
- Jeffrey M.
- Verified Homebuyer
- July 31, 2025
- Las Vegas, NV
Have nothing good to share. Lending department was nothing but harassment for months, several structural concerns that are being ignored, HOA that demands everything but returns nothing. Still stuck in legal mitigation over a solar lease we were forced into by Shea and told that it is our problem. Product and experience is not worth the money.
Shea Homes responded:
Hi Jeffrey- We have shared your comments with our team and our Warranty Manager has reached out to you to learn more about your concerns.
Total Score 2
Quality 2
Trustworthiness 1
Responsiveness 1
Buying a Shea Home Exceeded our Expectations
- Anonymous
- Verified Homebuyer
- July 30, 2025
- San Tan Valley, AZ
Meeting Linda and Destiny in the Shea center was a great and helpful start for the entire experience. They were patient, informative, and always available. We loved the design of the homes, the extra care given to building materials, and the quality of the home compared with the many other builders that we toured. People always talk about their "dream home" - and we feel like we finally found ours.
Total Score 5
Quality 5
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 5
Miss
- Yu S.
- Verified Homebuyer
- July 29, 2025
- Encinitas, CA
Shea Homes sales representatives are exceptional. They are professional and efficient. My emails and text messages are always responded within minutes. Their customer service team is super helpful as well. It ensured a smooth and pleasant purchase and move-in process. The quality and technology included in my new home are advanced. Shea Homes also provided complimentary white glove services to setup each systems. I believe this new property has great potential in value.
Total Score 5
Quality 5
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 5
Everyone was very responsive
- Steve K.
- Verified Homebuyer
- July 29, 2025
- San Tan Valley, AZ
We are very pleased with our home and the Shea homes staff.
Total Score 5
Quality 5
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 5
Fantastic Home, Well Built, Excellent After Sales Service!
- Thomas M.
- Verified Homebuyer
- July 28, 2025
- Castle Rock, CO
We recently built a Stonehaven in the Canyons. James was our Field Supervisor and Jill is our warranty specialist. James has great attention to detail and even one of the Douglas County housing inspectors told me : "this team at the Canyons builds some of the best homes I've ever seen". The fellow from CDI (a free Shea service) got all our locks, garage doors, HVAC, and light dimmers talking to one another, loaded them on our phones, and connected to Alexa. At our one month warranty check in , Jill got the 3 minor issues we had resolved quickly. We love our house, our neighbors are great and ...
Total Score 5
Quality 5
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 5
Narrow Reviews by Area
Floorplan Name:
saved to favorites!
To see all the homes you’ve saved, visit the My Favorites section of your account.
Floorplan Name:
Home by [BUILDERNAME]
Builder Reviews Total Score in all areas
Here is a list of all the communities where this floor plan is available. Click to see pricing and community information.