10 Best Neighborhoods in Indianapolis, IN to Live In

Moving to Indianapolis, IN?

Indianapolis combines Midwestern hospitality with urban amenities and diverse neighborhoods.

Why it matters: Selecting the right area and home influences your daily life, from schools to social scenes, in Indiana's capital.

What’s ahead: A concise look at Indy's top neighborhoods according to Niche, emphasizing livability, culture, and community feel.

1. Wynnedale-Spring Hill

Wynnedale-Spring Hill — Hidden gem with mid-century charm and leafy streets.

Population: 4,605 | Median Home Value: $285K | School Rating: A-

• Housing: 1950s–70s ranch + Tudor homes on quiet lots

• Safety: Low crime rates

• Education: Highly rated Indianapolis Public Schools, near Marion University

• Perks: Proximity to Riverside Park, Newfields Art Museum

• Vibe: Timeless, calm, and well-maintained

Why it’s #1: Peaceful living with quick access to cultural institutions.

2. North Central

North Central — Suburban energy meets urban convenience

Population: 6,749 | Median Home Value: $435K | School Rating: A-

• Housing: Diverse styles from Craftsman to contemporary

• Safety: Stable community with active neighborhood associations

• Education: Metropolitan School District of Washington Township, near Butler University

• Perks: Close to bars and restaurants, Monon Trail access

• Vibe: Active, social, and family-friendly with popularity among young professionals

Why it’s great: All the perks of the city without giving up space or safety.

3. Delaware Trails

Delaware Trails — Family-friendly suburb with a love for the outdoors.

Population: 8,141 | Median Home Value: $292K | School Rating: A-

Housing: Affordable single-family homes

• Safety: Safe community with engaged residents

• Education: IPS public schools, KIPP Indy College Prep Middle School, near Butler University

• Perks: Holliday Park, proximity to downtown

• Vibe: Active, outdoorsy, and community-focused

Why it’s on the list: Built for families who want trails over traffic.

4. Broad Ripple

Broad Ripple — Creative heart of Indy with indie flair.

Population: 7,252 | Median Home Value: $336K | School Rating: B-

• Housing: Historic homes with character

• Safety: Strong neighborhood watch

• Education: Above average Indianapolis Public Schools, Butler University

• Perks: Indianapolis Art Center, Broad Ripple Park, and craft breweries

• Vibe: Eclectic, creative, and lively

The draw: Perfect for creatives who crave walkability and culture.

5. Clearwater

Clearwater — A peaceful nook near all your essentials.

Population: 3,767 | Median Home Value: $312K | School Rating: A

• Housing: Mix of single-family homes with spacious yards

• Safety: Secure, low crime rates

• Education: Top tier MSD Washington Township, Purdue Global campus nearby

• Perks: Proximity to parks and Keystone Crossing

• Vibe: Quiet, family-oriented, and upscale

What’s noteworthy: Tucked away but close to everything Indy offers.

6. Glendale

Glendale — Retail-ready with a suburban soul.

Population: 4,038 | Median Home Value: $335K | School Rating: A-

• Housing: Affordable homes

• Safety: Safe streets, community-focused

• Education: IPS district

• Perks: Close to Indiana State Fairgrounds, Fort Harrison State Park

• Vibe: Quiet, retiree-friendly, and community-focused

The allure: Big-box and boutique shopping meets neighborhood charm.

7. Butler-Tarkington

Butler-Tarkington — Historic homes meet university-town vibe.

Population: 9,793 | Median Home Value: $341K | School Rating: B-

• Housing: Colonial, Craftsman, and Tudor architecture

• Safety: Active neighborhood associations

• Education: Indianapolis Public Schools, Butler University

• Perks: Close to downtown, Tarkington Park

• Vibe: Historic, walkable, and culturally rich

Why it works: A beautiful blend of historic charm and modern conveniences.

8. Allisonville

Allisonville — Diverse and growing, with something for everyone.

Population: 10,081 | Median Home Value: $368K | School Rating: A-

• Housing: Range of ranch, split-level, and modern builds

• Safety: Stable community with active neighborhood associations

• Education: MSD Washington Township, Butler University

• Perks: Close to bars and restaurants, Fort Harrison State Park, Sahm Park

• Vibe: Active, community-oriented, and family-friendly

The takeaway: A versatile hub for families, young professionals, and first-time buyers.

9. Traders Point

Traders Point — Green, serene, and a retreat from the rush.

Population: 6,446 | Median Home Value: $402K | School Rating: B-

• Housing: Affordable options, country-style lots

• Safety: Rural-suburban, low crime

• Education: MSD Pike Township schools,

• Perks: Indianapolis International Airport, Traders Point Creamery

• Vibe: Quiet, retiree-friendly, and community-focused

Why it shines: For nature-lovers who want space without sprawl.

10. Geist

Geist — Waterfront lifestyle just outside the city buzz.

Population: 12,535 | Median Home Value: $456K | School Rating: B

• Housing: Mix of single-family, luxury, and lakefront homes

• Safety: Exceptionally secure

• Education: Hamilton Southeastern Schools, near IU satellite

• Perks: Geist Reservoir, marina dining, kayaking

• Vibe: Luxe, outdoorsy, and relaxed

Worth mentioning: The go-to for those craving lake life without leaving town.

Bottom Line

Whether you're chasing walkable culture, lakeside peace, or leafy family vibes, Indy's top suburbs serve up charm, safety, and access—with personality to match.

Other Indiana Resources:

Moving To Indianapolis? This Relocation Guide Will Help

Best Suburbs Surrounding Indianapolis

First-Time Homebuyer Programs in Indiana

Your Guide to 2021 Indiana Closing Costs

Top 10 Safest Cities in Indiana

Most Affordable Cities in Indiana

20 Most Affordable States

10 Best State Parks in Indiana