Buying Rental Property: A Smart FAQ for New Construction Homebuyers

By Julie Gordey

Jan. 24, 2026 at 1:00 PM CST

Bottom line: Rental property can be a powerful wealth-building tool – but it’s a long game, not passive income. The best results come from smart planning, realistic expectations, and low-maintenance homes.

Is Rental Investing a Good Fit?

Rental ownership offers:But it also means:
Steady income potentialLegal responsibility for tenants
Long-term appreciationUnexpected repairs
Tax advantagesOngoing cash and time commitments

If you’re financially stable and patient, rental investing can pair well with new construction – especially homes designed for durability and efficiency.

What Is a Rental Property?

A rental property is a home purchased as an investment and leased to tenants under a formal agreement.

This article focuses on residential rental properties (single-family homes, townhomes, condos), which are often the easiest entry point for first-time investors.

Why New Construction Makes Sense for Rentals

New construction homes offer built-in advantages:

  • Fewer repairs in early years

  • Modern systems and energy efficiency

  • Builder warranties that reduce risk

  • Strong appeal to long-term tenants

Many buyers start by living in their new home and later converting it into a rental – a strategy known as house hacking.

How Much Does a Rental Property Cost?

Investment properties typically require:

  • 20–25% down payment

  • Strong credit

  • Higher interest rates than owner-occupied loans

  • Cash reserves (often several months of expenses)

Newer homes help offset higher borrowing costs by minimizing maintenance surprises.

Are There Tax Benefits?

Yes. According to the IRS, rental property owners may deduct:

  • Mortgage interest

  • Property taxes

  • Insurance

  • Repairs and maintenance

  • Utilities (if owner-paid)

  • Depreciation

Rules differ for properties with personal use, such as vacation homes. Depreciation recapture may also apply when you sell, so tax planning matters.

What Should My Profit Margins Be?

Smart investors focus on cash flow and sustainability, not just rent price.

Typical benchmarks:Budget for:
Operating expenses: ~50% of gross rentAnnual maintenance (~1% of home value)
Example: $1,000 rent → ~$500 in expensesInsurance
HOA fees
Healthy first-year return: ~6%Landscaping and pest control
Capital improvements over time

First-time investors should generally avoid fixer-uppers – especially when new construction offers more predictable costs.

Do I Need Special Insurance?

Yes. Standard homeowner policies usually do not cover rentals.

A landlord insurance policy typically includes:

  • Property damage coverage

  • Liability protection

  • Lost rental income due to covered events

Rates vary, so shop carefully.

Can I Hire Someone to Manage the Property?

Absolutely. Property managers can handle:

  • Tenant screening

  • Rent collection

  • Maintenance coordination

  • Legal compliance

Cost: Usually 8–12% of monthly rent Trade-off: Less stress, lower net profit

For new investors, professional management can prevent costly mistakes.

Why Do Investors Choose Rentals?

Real estate investor Mark Ferguson explains:

“One of the great benefits of real estate is controlling a large asset with little money … a small down payment increases your returns versus making a 100 percent investment elsewhere.”

  • Rental properties reward time, consistency, and smart leverage

  • They are not a get-rich-quick strategy – but they are proven long-term performers.

Smart Extras New Construction Buyers Should Consider

Before you buy check into:
Local landlord laws (vary by city and state)Professional advice: lender, CPA, property manager
Exit strategies: sell, refinance, or move back inBuild-to-rent trends in your market

Final Takeaway

Rental investing works best when you:

  • Start with a low-maintenance home

  • Run the numbers conservatively

  • Plan for long-term ownership

  • Stay patient

For many new construction buyers, a rental property isn’t just a first investment – it’s a future opportunity waiting to mature.

For help in finding that perfect new home property, check out NewHomeSource for the most complete listings of new home communities.

Follow NewHomeSource on Instagram and Facebook.


Julie Gordey

A lifelong educator, Julie Gordey, is a retired school administrator.  After years of focusing on education, this University of Texas graduate now travels and enjoys freelance writing for BDX and NewHomeSource.com.