Welcome to Idaho, the potato capital of the United States! Although best known for its potatoes, Idaho is also a leading producer of lentils and trout. Additionally, Idaho has earned its nickname of the Gem State for its bountiful precious and semi-precious stones.
Framed by beautiful mountains and valleys, Idaho truly is a treasure. Ready to make a move out west? With stunning beauty and outdoor recreation awaiting you, a move to Idaho is an easy choice. We’ve compiled a list of the 10 safest cities in the state to help inform your choice.
The "Safest Cities" series evaluates and ranks the safest cities in each U.S. state using crime data from the FBI and state databases. Our analysis considers population size, violent and nonviolent crime rates, the most common crime, and comparisons to national and state averages. Violent crimes include homicide, assault, robbery, and sexual assault, while nonviolent crimes encompass burglary, theft, and vehicle-related offenses. Each city’s safety score is weighted, emphasizing violent crimes. Data inconsistencies and reporting variations are acknowledged as limitations. This analysis aims to help individuals and families make informed decisions about where to live.
1. Rexburg
Population: 28,765
Violent Crimes: 14
Nonviolent Crimes: 120
Most Common Crime: Theft
Rexburg, Idaho, is a city tucked into the rolling plains of eastern Idaho, just a short drive from the rugged beauty of the Teton and Sawtooth mountain ranges. Situated in Madison County, Rexburg is about 30 miles northeast of Idaho Falls and roughly an hour and a half’s drive to Jackson, Wyoming, with Yellowstone National Park practically in its backyard. Known as “America’s Family Community,” Rexburg radiates a distinct small-town warmth and a strong community spirit that draws people looking for both adventure and peace.
Safety is a priority here. Rexburg enjoys one of the lowest crime rates in the state, thanks to a dedicated police force and a tight-knit community that actively looks out for one another. Programs like the Neighborhood Watch and school outreach initiatives build relationships between residents and law enforcement, reinforcing a sense of shared responsibility.
Rexburg is home to Brigham Young University-Idaho, a four-year liberal arts university, as well as a strongly performing public education system. The university brings in a mix of students from all over, adding a cosmopolitan flair to this otherwise rural setting. For those new to town, BYU-Idaho’s influence is a major asset, drawing in cultural events, lectures, and sporting events year-round. And for families, the schools are part of Madison School District, known for its academic rigor and extracurricular opportunities, offering an excellent environment for children.
Healthcare in Rexburg is covered by Madison Memorial Hospital, a well-equipped facility with a reputation for quality care and friendly service. The hospital is supported by various clinics around town. Nearby Idaho Falls provides additional healthcare options, including a broader range of specialized services and treatment centers.
Enjoy having nature’s playground at your doorstep. The Snake River, Yellowstone, and the Teton Mountain Range are all within striking distance, offering activities like fishing, hiking, skiing, and camping that are unbeatable for the outdoor enthusiast. Rexburg itself has an active lifestyle culture, with local parks, green spaces, and bike trails that make it easy to stay engaged and active. Dining and shopping tend toward the locally owned, with charming cafes and unique boutiques giving Rexburg’s Main Street character and making it a fun place to explore on a weekend afternoon.
People come to Rexburg for the tight-knit community and the rare chance to live in a place that’s both tranquil and dynamic. Between the safety, the friendly vibe, the educational opportunities, and proximity to some of the country’s most breathtaking landscapes, Rexburg offers a quality of life that’s hard to replicate.
2. Middleton
Population: 11,016
Violent Crimes: 22
Nonviolent Crimes: 72
Most Common Crime: Theft
Middleton has jumped two spots to become the second safest city in Idaho. The oldest settlement in Canyon County, Middleton is a small town with a lot of history, including as a stage station on the Oregon Trail. Modern Middleton boasts a motto of “Life Is Better Here,” and with the median house price averaging in the mid-$200,000s, it’s a motto well earned.
Middleton, Idaho, is a small town on the western edge of the Treasure Valley, about 30 minutes from Boise and close enough to Nampa and Caldwell to enjoy their amenities without sacrificing a quieter lifestyle. The oldest settlement in Canyon County, Middleton is a small town with a lot of history, including as a stage station on the Oregon Trail.
Positioned along the Boise River, Middleton has a laid-back charm and a close community feel that draws people seeking a slower pace without leaving behind Idaho's distinctive sense of adventure. It’s known as “The First Town in Idaho,” and locals carry that sense of heritage proudly, nurturing the town’s historical roots and small-town character.
Middleton is a safe place to call home, and the community is serious about keeping it that way. Local police work closely with residents, and there’s a strong sense of shared responsibility when it comes to neighborhood safety. Community programs like Middleton’s “Safe Routes to School” initiative encourage children to walk or bike safely, emphasizing that sense of security in everyday life.
Families in Middleton find a strong support system in the Middleton School District, which has earned a solid reputation in recent years. With growing interest in both academics and sports, the schools provide ample opportunities for students to thrive in a supportive environment. For healthcare, residents typically look to nearby hospitals in Caldwell and Nampa, which offer a range of medical services.
Life in Middleton means taking advantage of Idaho’s open spaces. Local parks and the nearby Boise River offer fishing, kayaking, and scenic spots for picnics and relaxation. The town hosts family-friendly events throughout the year, such as farmers' markets and festivals, creating opportunities to connect and make memories with neighbors.
Make Middleton your new home destination in Idaho.
3. Rathdrum
Population: 11,580
Violent Crimes: 7
Nonviolent Crimes: 97
Most Common Crime: Larceny and Burglary
In Rathdrum, Idaho, located in the scenic Panhandle region just 20 minutes from Coeur d’Alene, you’ll find a mix of mountain views, forests, and a peaceful rural vibe. Close to the Idaho-Washington border, Rathdrum is a haven for those seeking a balance between the outdoor beauty of northern Idaho and access to the conveniences of larger towns. The area is safe, and local law enforcement takes an active role in maintaining that, with community events and a visible presence that reassures residents and visitors alike.
Rathdrum’s history runs deep, with its roots as a railway town and its position as one of the oldest cities in Idaho, founded in 1881. Today, this historical background gives Rathdrum a unique character. Schools in Rathdrum are part of the Lakeland School District, known for its commitment to quality education. For healthcare, residents rely on nearby medical centers in Coeur d’Alene, but Rathdrum also has several family clinics for convenient local care.
With the mountains and lakes nearby, Rathdrum is ideal for anyone who loves outdoor activities like hiking, skiing, and fishing. Residents enjoy Hayden Lake, Silverwood Theme Park, and the broader Coeur d’Alene area for recreation and relaxation. Dining is local and friendly, with a small-town charm that encourages you to get to know the owners of the cafes and shops. Rathdrum’s community events, such as summer concerts and holiday parades, enhance the neighborly feel of the town.
Give Rathdrum some serious consideration. This welcoming city in Kootenai County has much to offer for a serene Idaho lifestyle.
4. Preston
Population: 6,112
Violent Crimes: 7
Nonviolent Crimes: 28
Most Common Crime: Theft
Located in Franklin County, Preston is a small, thriving town in southeastern Idaho. It is known for its picturesque valley setting and small-town hospitality. Located about 20 miles from Logan, Utah, and 100 miles north of Salt Lake City, Preston combines Idaho’s laid-back atmosphere with the convenience of nearby larger cities.
It is known for its emphasis on community, which can be seen in annual traditions like the holiday Festival of Lights. With mountains and parks within drivable distance, there’s always something to do. Safety is a given in Preston, where community ties are strong and locals keep an eye out for one another.
This is a town that achieved pop-culture fame as the filming location for Napoleon Dynamite, and it embraces this quirky reputation with local events and celebrations tied to the film. Schools are well-regarded here, with the Preston School District offering quality education and strong community involvement. Healthcare needs are met by nearby Franklin County Medical Center, which provides a range of services to the residents of Preston and surrounding communities.
For those who love the outdoors, Preston’s location near Bear Lake and the Cache National Forest offers numerous activities, including camping, boating, fishing, and skiing. Preston has a thriving local dining scene, with several restaurants that serve up hearty meals and showcase local flavors. Annual events like the Franklin County Fair bring the community together, and the historic Oneida Stake Academy is a reminder of the town’s rich history.
Preston's scenic setting, strong sense of community, and proximity to recreational areas make it an appealing spot for those who enjoy rural living with a splash of small-town charm.
5. Hailey
Population: 9,824
Violent Crimes: 23
Nonviolent Crimes: 55
Most Common Crime: Larceny and Burglary
Hailey, Idaho, nestled in the Wood River Valley and part of the Sun Valley area, combines the beauty of the Rockies with a small-town, mountain-town vibe. About 13 miles south of Ketchum and just a quick 20-minute drive from the famous Sun Valley Resort, Hailey sits as a gateway to outdoor adventures while retaining its own unique flair.
It’s a safe, welcoming community with an active police presence and close-knit neighborhoods that come together to keep an eye out for one another. It’s also known as “Idaho’s Hometown in the Mountains,” and that rings true in every street corner and community gathering.
Hailey is distinct for its blend of art, history, and outdoor fun. People are drawn to the town for the breathtaking landscapes and outdoor access, but they find themselves staying for the sense of place and vibrant culture.
The community offers excellent healthcare options, including the St. Luke’s Wood River Medical Center, just up the road, and a range of family clinics. Hailey schools are part of the Blaine County School District, which offers strong educational programs and community support. For higher education, Boise is about two hours away.
Hailey’s draw is easy access to skiing, hiking, fishing, and more in the stunning mountains and rivers that define the area. Locals and visitors alike enjoy year-round events like the Northern Rockies Folk Festival and Hailey’s “Trails Day,” and historic buildings downtown make for an inviting dining and shopping experience.
Hailey’s unique position in Idaho—a small, artsy town within reach of both big adventure and the upscale Sun Valley lifestyle—makes it stand out.
6. Fruitland
Population: 6,879
Violent Crimes: 7
Nonviolent Crimes: 47
Most Common Crime: Burglary and Larceny
Fruitland, Idaho, located in southwestern Idaho near the Oregon border, is part of the quiet, agricultural Payette County and less than an hour from Boise. Known as the “Big Apple of Idaho,” Fruitland has earned its title for its abundance of orchards and vineyards. The area has a relaxed rural feel and is known for safety and community-minded neighbors who support local law enforcement efforts to keep the town safe.
This tight-knit community offers excellent education options within the Fruitland School District, recognized for its high standards and support for students. For healthcare, nearby Ontario, Oregon, has Saint Alphonsus Medical Center, and Fruitland itself has smaller clinics that meet primary needs. The town’s economy is bolstered by agriculture, with local farms and small businesses that keep the community bustling.
Living in Fruitland means savoring outdoor pursuits like fishing in the Snake River, exploring nearby parks, and enjoying the annual Fruitland Family Fun Days. The small downtown area offers cozy cafes, family-run restaurants, and shops where locals catch up on town news.
Fruitland’s charm lies in its blend of rural comfort, farming culture, and its close proximity to larger amenities in Ontario and Boise.
7. Moscow
Population: 26,387
Violent Crimes: 3
Nonviolent Crimes: 394
Most Common Crime: Larceny and Burglary
Moscow is located along the Washington border and acts as the county seat of Latah County. Moscow is home to the University of Idaho, which serves more than 11,000 students annually. The university gives this small town a big city feel, thanks to its lively campus and vibrant community events. This college town is one of the safest around.
About 85 miles south of Spokane, Washington, Moscow is known for its progressive character, historic architecture, and the nickname “Heart of the Arts” due to its focus on culture and creativity. The town has a strong reputation for safety, and locals benefit from several community-focused safety programs that aim to protect its residents.
Moscow stands out for its artistic and educational offerings. The town’s healthcare is robust, supported by Gritman Medical Center, a well-regarded hospital that serves the broader region. Moscow’s schools are highly rated, with strong academic programs and a focus on creating a welcoming environment for all students.
Life in Moscow is enriched by local events, farmers’ markets, and the beautiful landscapes that surround the Palouse. Downtown Moscow is a hub of activity, with unique shops, art galleries, and community theaters. For outdoor lovers, Moscow Mountain and the nearby rivers offer hiking, fishing, and camping opportunities.
Moscow’s blend of college-town energy, artsy vibe, and natural beauty makes it a standout in Idaho. It should make your Idaho short list.
8. Meridian
Population: 134,801
Violent Crimes: 215
Nonviolent Crimes: 675
Most Common Crime: Larceny and Burglary
Meridian is not only one of the safest cities in Idaho but also the second largest. Meridian has transformed from a quiet farming community into one of Idaho’s fastest-growing cities. One reason this city is growing so fast is its prime location. Parks and mountains surround Meridian, and the state capital of Boise is less than 15 miles away. Despite its growth, Meridian honors its history as a dairy-related village by hosting Meridian Dairy Days every June.
Meridian has an excellent reputation for safety, supported by proactive community programs and a responsive local police force. Nicknamed the “Center of the Treasure Valley,” Meridian has everything you’d expect in a thriving suburban town, from top-tier shopping to an abundance of local parks.
St. Luke’s Meridian Medical Center ensures that residents have easy access to quality healthcare, while the West Ada School District, Idaho’s largest, provides a range of educational options for students. Higher education is easily accessible in Boise, including Boise State University.
Meridian offers an enviable range of activities, from family outings at Roaring Springs Water Park to cultural events and concerts. The city is also a great spot for food lovers, with a mix of restaurants ranging from casual eateries to upscale dining.
For anyone seeking a balanced life with access to both outdoor adventures and the amenities of a larger city, Meridian strikes a sweet spot. Enjoy friendliness that makes every newcomer feel welcome.
9. Emmett
Population: 8,492
Violent Crimes: 40
Nonviolent Crimes: 50
Most Common Crime: Larceny and Theft
Emmett is the one and only city located in Gem County, north of Boise. As the county’s name implies, the area was a hotspot for mining. Although the mines closed, Emmett thrived as an agricultural community due to the fertile valley land. The nearby Black Canyon Park along the Payette River offers plenty of opportunities for outdoor fun.
Emmett’s rural vibe, scenic views, and close-knit community make it feel like a world away from the hustle of the big city. Known for its safety and strong community values, Emmett benefits from a local police force that works closely with residents to keep the town secure and welcoming.
Emmett is known for its fruit orchards and agricultural heritage, which have been celebrated with the annual Emmett Cherry Festival for over 80 years. Residents love the peace and simplicity here, along with easy access to outdoor pursuits, from fishing and kayaking on the Payette River to hiking trails around the valley.
Saint Alphonsus Medical Center in Ontario and the larger facilities in Boise provide nearby healthcare options, while local clinics serve Emmett’s day-to-day needs. Schools in the Emmett School District have a reputation for small class sizes and supportive teachers, making it a comfortable place for families to raise children.
Living in Emmett means enjoying the great outdoors, local events, and a slow-paced lifestyle with all the essentials. You’ll find quaint shops, diners, and family-owned businesses downtown, and a friendly atmosphere that makes new residents feel like family. For those drawn to Idaho’s natural beauty but looking to escape the fast growth in cities like Boise, Emmett offers a serene retreat with all the charm of an agricultural town.
10. Payette
Population: 8,636
Violent Crimes: 135
Nonviolent Crimes: 69
Most Common Crime: Larceny and Burglary
Rounding out the top 10 list is Payette, the county seat of Payette County. About 60 miles northwest of Boise, Payette blends small-town charm with a pioneering spirit, drawing on its roots as a former railroad and timber town. It’s a community that values its heritage and takes pride in its close connections. Payette has a reputation for being safe, with community programs and a local police department dedicated to maintaining peace of mind for all who call it home.
Known as the "Gateway to the Treasure Valley," Payette offers easy access to both outdoor adventures and urban amenities. The Payette River, a haven for fishing and rafting, is a major local draw, along with the surrounding farmlands and nearby state parks. This small town has over 51 acres of community parkland, in addition to the natural wonders of the Snake River. Golf enthusiasts can visit the Scotch Pines Golf Course, which includes a newly remodeled clubhouse.
Healthcare needs are served by nearby facilities, such as Saint Alphonsus Medical Center in Ontario, while local clinics handle routine care. Payette schools, part of the Payette School District, offer supportive education, with a strong sense of community and school pride. Colleges in Boise are within reach for those pursuing higher education.
Downtown Payette has an old-fashioned, Western feel, with family-owned shops, diners, and cafés that locals love. Living here means being part of a strong community, enjoying river activities, and exploring Idaho’s expansive landscapes.
While larger cities nearby offer more extensive amenities, Payette’s simplicity and charm attract residents who value tradition, natural beauty, and a close community. Payette is a welcoming choice.
Other Idaho Resources
Best Tiny Home Builders in Idaho
The Top 10 Most Affordable Cities in Idaho
The 10 Best Places to Retire in Idaho
First-Time Homebuyer Programs in Idaho
Sarah Scott
Sarah graduated from Trinity University in 2012 with a degree in International Relations and Political Science. She writes blogs on new homes, decor, communities, and more for NewHomeSource. When she's not writing, you can find her spending time with her three cats.