Skip main navigation
Interior
Interior
Interior
Front Exterior
Interior
Kitchen
Kitchen
Interior
Bathroom
Bedroom
Interior
Interior
Bedroom
Bathroom
Interior
Back to Grove City, Ohio
Quick move-in A home that is move-in ready, or is already under construction. Under Construction

1191 Jeffrey Lane

Grove City, OH 43123

$521,870 This is the set price for this quick move-in. Optional upgrades may be available and could affect the total cost — subject to your builder.

M/I Homes Logo

M/I Homes

Evanston in Pinnacle Quarry

  • 4 Beds
  • 2.5 Baths
  • 2 Car garage
  • 2,481 Sq Ft

Overview

Home features

  • 1 Half Bathroom
  • 2 Stories
  • Primary Bed Upstairs
  • Single Family

Home description

Discover 1191 Jeffrey Lane in Grove City, Ohio — a stunning new construction home built by M/I Homes. This 2-story residence offers 2,481 square feet of thoughtfully designed living space, featuring 4 bedrooms, 2.5 bathrooms, and a full basement that provides excellent additional space for storage or future finishing. Step inside to find an open-concept main level that creates a seamless flow between gathering areas, ideal for everyday living and entertaining. Well-proportioned rooms, clean lines, and a carefully considered layout highlight the quality of design throughout, maximizing both comfort and functionality.   Key Features: 2-car garage Covered porch Mud room  Flex room Bonus room The second floor is anchored by a private owner’s suite, complete with a spaci...

Discover 1191 Jeffrey Lane in Grove City, Ohio — a stunning new construction home built by M/I Homes. This 2-story residence offers 2,481 square feet of thoughtfully designed living space, featuring 4 bedrooms, 2.5 bathrooms, and a full basement that provides excellent additional space for storage or future finishing. Step inside to find an open-concept main level that creates a seamless flow between gathering areas, ideal for everyday living and entertaining. Well-proportioned rooms, clean lines, and a carefully considered layout highlight the quality of design throughout, maximizing both comfort and functionality.   Key Features: 2-car garage Covered porch Mud room  Flex room Bonus room The second floor is anchored by a private owner’s suite, complete with a spacious en-suite bathroom that serves as a relaxing retreat at the end of the day. Three additional bedrooms share convenient access to the hall bathroom, offering flexibility for family, guests, or to serve as a home office. One of the standout features of this home is the expansive bonus room, providing an impressive amount of additional living space. Whether used as a media room, playroom, home gym, or future lounge area, this oversized room adapts easily to your lifestyle. This home is situated in a welcoming community with convenient proximity to parks, making it an ideal setting for those who enjoy outdoor recreation and green sp... MLS# 226023711

Explore this home

Explore custom options for this floor plan.

Special offers

Explore the latest promotions at Pinnacle Quarry. to learn more!

Financing

Make Your Move Before Labor Day

Save big before Labor Day with lower monthly payments on your dream home with rates as low as 4.875% Rate* / 5.64% APR* on 30-year fixed FHA loans through M/I Financial, LLC* on select Quick Move-In Homes that can close before November 30th, 2026. This offer runs through 09/06/2026.

Learn more
Financing

Labor Day Savings

Thinking about buying a new home, but worried about high interest rates? Take advantage of our featured offer through M/I Financial, LLC to lock in an extended below-market rate* This offer runs through 09/06/2026.

Learn more

Community highlights

Community amenities

  • Basketball

  • Club House

  • Community Center

  • Golf Course

  • Park

  • Playground

  • Pond

  • Trails

About Pinnacle Quarry

Pinnacle Quarry is a new single family home community in Grove City, Ohio, offering a private, scenic setting just minutes from everyday conveniences. Located near Stringtown Road with easy access to I-71, the community makes it simple to reach shopping, dining, and Downtown Columbus while enjoying a quieter place to call home. Homes at Pinnacle Quarry include ranch, two-story, and split-level designs with open, functional layouts. Floorplans are thoughtfully designed to support daily living, entertaining, and flexible use of space, with architectural styles that add character and a sense of individuality throughout the neighborhood. The community is surrounded by more than 70 acres of reserve space and offers access to an exceptional lineup of amenities. Residents can enjoy a pool, privat...

Pinnacle Quarry is a new single family home community in Grove City, Ohio, offering a private, scenic setting just minutes from everyday conveniences. Located near Stringtown Road with easy access to I-71, the community makes it simple to reach shopping, dining, and Downtown Columbus while enjoying a quieter place to call home. Homes at Pinnacle Quarry include ranch, two-story, and split-level designs with open, functional layouts. Floorplans are thoughtfully designed to support daily living, entertaining, and flexible use of space, with architectural styles that add character and a sense of individuality throughout the neighborhood. The community is surrounded by more than 70 acres of reserve space and offers access to an exceptional lineup of amenities. Residents can enjoy a pool, private golf course, fitness center, and basketball and tennis courts, along with wooded surroundings that enhance the relaxed atmosphere. Nearby parks, local restaurants, and retail add to everyday convenience. Served by the South-Western City School District, Pinnacle Quarry delivers a lifestyle that blends comfort, recreation, and connection in one of Grove City’s most appealing locations. More info about Pinnacle Quarry

Have questions about the amenities?

Get more details

By providing your name and contact information and clicking the Download brochure button, you consent and agree to receive marketing communications from NewHomeSource and M/I Homes selected above, including emails, calls or text messages using an automatic telephone dialing system or an artificial or prerecorded voice. By providing your name and contact information and clicking the Download brochure button, you consent and agree to receive marketing communications from NewHomeSource and M/I Homes selected above, including emails, calls or text messages using an automatic telephone dialing system or an artificial or prerecorded voice. Your agreement is not a condition to purchasing any property, goods or services, and you may call us instead of submitting the information online. You also acknowledge and agree that you can revoke your authorization at any time. Your consent herein also applies to any future registration on national or state Do-No-Call lists. For mobile phones, standard message and data charges apply. Consult our Privacy Policy for additional information, including unsubscribe options. You also agree to our Privacy Policy, including TCPA Policy and Terms of Use. Show More

Your free brochure has been sent via email

Request a tour

Home location

1191 Jeffrey Lane, Grove City, OH 43123

Community location & sales center
Evanston

Pinnacle Quarry
M/I Homes
899 Heimat Haus Drive, Grove City, OH 43123

888-***-****

Sales Agent

Lauren Kuhn

Hours

Mon-Wed 11am-6pm; By Appointment Only Thu-Fri; Sat-Sun 11am-6pm

Neighborhood

Community map

Community location & sales center

899 Heimat Haus Drive Grove City, OH 43123

888-***-****

Please enter a valid location or select an item from the list.
Driving directions to sales center

Schools near Pinnacle Quarry

South-western City Schools

Public Elementary School

GreatSchools
rating GreatSchools rating: 10 out of 10

Buckeye Woods Elementary School

Grades PK to 5

614-801-8025

2525 Holton Rd, Grove City, OH, 43123

Class ratio
1:22

Enrollment
753

Public Elementary-Middle School

GreatSchools
rating GreatSchools rating: 7 out of 10

Park Street Intermediate School

Grades PK to 8

614-801-8800

3205 Park St, Grove City, OH, 43123

Class ratio
1:19

Enrollment
700

Public Middle School

GreatSchools
rating GreatSchools rating: 6 out of 10

Jackson Middle School

Grades 6 to 8

614-801-3800

2271 Holton Rd, Grove City, OH, 43123

Class ratio
1:19

Enrollment
675

Public High School

GreatSchools
rating GreatSchools rating: 5 out of 10

Grove City High School

Grades 9 to 12

614-801-3300

4665 Hoover Rd, Grove City, OH, 43123

Class ratio
1:20

Enrollment
1881

GreatSchools ratings are provided by GreatSchools.org and are for reference only. Ratings may not be available for all schools. Please verify school assignments and details with the local school district.

Amenities

Community & neighborhood

Local points of interest

  • Downtown Grove City
  • Grove City Library
  • Mount Carmel Grove City
  • Scioto Grove Metro Park
  • Downtown Columbus
  • Grove City YMCA
  • Big Splash Pool
  • Eldorado Scioto Downs
  • Pinnacle Golf Course
  • Mount Carmel Grove City Hospital
  • Ohio Health Grove City Methodist Hospital
  • Pond

Social activities

  • Club House

Health and fitness

  • Golf Course
  • Trails
  • Basketball

Community services & perks

  • Playground
  • Park
  • Community Center

Builder details

M/I Homes

M/I Homes Logo

M/I Homes has been building new homes of outstanding quality and superior design for more than 50 years. Founded in 1976 by Irving and Melvin Schottenstein, and guided by Irving’s drive to always “treat the customer right,” we’ve fulfilled the dreams of more than 170,000 homeowners, and grown to become one of the nation’s leading homebuilders.

View full builder profile > View builder's website >

This listing's information was verified with the builder for accuracy 1 day ago