Bedrooms
Bathrooms
Filters
Home Price
Move-In Date
School district
Builders
Bedrooms
Bathrooms
Living Areas
Stories/Floors
Primary Bedroom
Garages
Community Amenities
Active Adults (55+) Communities
Other Filters

New Construction Homes in Shelbyville, IN

743 Homes

Explore more options within Shelby County, IN See all Homes

Need a hint? Follow these search tips
  1. Expand Your Search: Adjust filters to broaden your search or Clear your filters.
  2. Map Location: Activate the 'Search within the map' switch to find homes within the visible map area.
  3. Explore Another Location: Consider searching in a different area.

Check out our top recommendations

From $311,995

3 Br | 2.5 Ba | 2 Gr | 2,300 sq ft

Reagan | Shelbyville, IN

Silverthorne Homes

From $332,995

4 Br | 2.5 Ba | 2 Gr | 2,929 sq ft

Van Buren | Shelbyville, IN

Silverthorne Homes

From $369,995

4 Br | 2.5 Ba | 2 Gr | 3,310 sq ft

Monroe | Shelbyville, IN

Silverthorne Homes

From $284,995

3 Br | 2 Ba | 1,802 sq ft

Eisenhower | Shelbyville, IN

Silverthorne Homes

From $337,995

5 Br | 2.5 Ba | 2 Gr | 2,961 sq ft

Lincoln | Shelbyville, IN

Silverthorne Homes

From $324,995

4 Br | 2.5 Ba | 2 Gr | 2,813 sq ft

Harrison | Shelbyville, IN

Silverthorne Homes

From $301,995

3 Br | 2.5 Ba | 2 Gr | 2,001 sq ft

Taylor | Shelbyville, IN

Silverthorne Homes

From $319,995

4 Br | 2.5 Ba | 2,606 sq ft

Arthur | Shelbyville, IN

Silverthorne Homes

Move-In Ready

$29,315

From $345,000 $374,315

3 Br | 2.5 Ba | 2 Gr | 2,169 sq ft Hot Deal

2338 William Garrett Way. Shelbyville, IN 46176

M/I Homes

From $335,990

3 Br | 2.5 Ba | 2 Gr | 2,570 sq ft Hot Deal

Attucks Slab | Shelbyville, IN

M/I Homes

From $315,990

3 Br | 2.5 Ba | 2 Gr | 2,169 sq ft Hot Deal

Hickory Slab | Shelbyville, IN

M/I Homes

From $309,990

3 Br | 2.5 Ba | 2 Gr | 1,995 sq ft Hot Deal

New Castle Slab | Shelbyville, IN

M/I Homes

From $290,990

3 Br | 2 Ba | 2 Gr | 1,520 sq ft Hot Deal

Hinkle Slab | Shelbyville, IN

M/I Homes

From $321,990

3 Br | 2.5 Ba | 2 Gr | 2,293 sq ft Hot Deal

Spring Valley Slab | Shelbyville, IN

M/I Homes

From $345,990

3 Br | 2.5 Ba | 2 Gr | 2,755 sq ft Hot Deal

Muncie Slab | Shelbyville, IN

M/I Homes

Model Home

Contact Builder for Details

3 Br | 2 Ba | 2 Gr | 1,585 sq ft Hot Deal

2326 William Garrett Way. Shelbyville, IN 46176

M/I Homes

Model Home

Contact Builder for Details

3 Br | 2.5 Ba | 2 Gr | 2,293 sq ft Hot Deal

2330 William Garrett Way. Shelbyville, IN 46176

M/I Homes

Move-In Ready

$24,165

From $294,990 $319,155

3 Br | 2 Ba | 2 Gr | 1,585 sq ft Hot Deal

2339 William Garrett Way. Shelbyville, IN 46176

M/I Homes

Move-In Ready

$36,000

From $339,990 $375,990

3 Br | 2.5 Ba | 2 Gr | 2,577 sq ft Hot Deal

2347 William Garrett Way. Shelbyville, IN 46176

M/I Homes

From $275,990

2 Br | 2 Ba | 2 Gr | 1,460 sq ft Hot Deal

Hulman | Shelbyville, IN

M/I Homes

Under Construction

$21,150

From $349,990 $371,140

3 Br | 2.5 Ba | 2 Gr | 2,180 sq ft Hot Deal

1821 James Pierce Drive. Shelbyville, IN 46176

M/I Homes

Under Construction

$20,325

From $324,990 $345,315

3 Br | 2 Ba | 2 Gr | 1,585 sq ft Hot Deal

1817 James Pierce Drive. Shelbyville, IN 46176

M/I Homes

Under Construction

$26,785

From $299,990 $326,775

3 Br | 2 Ba | 2 Gr | 1,520 sq ft Hot Deal

1814 James Pierce Drive. Shelbyville, IN 46176

M/I Homes

Under Construction

$21,450

From $337,990 $359,440

3 Br | 2.5 Ba | 2 Gr | 1,995 sq ft Hot Deal

1825 James Pierce Drive. Shelbyville, IN 46176

M/I Homes

Under Construction

$17,725

From $349,990 $367,715

3 Br | 2.5 Ba | 2 Gr | 2,169 sq ft Hot Deal

1810 James Pierce Drive. Shelbyville, IN 46176

M/I Homes

From $337,500

4 Br | 2.5 Ba | 2 Gr | 3,088 sq ft

Simplicity 3088 | Shelbyville, IN

Pyatt Builders

From $297,500

3 Br | 2.5 Ba | 2 Gr | 2,139 sq ft

Simplicity 2139 | Shelbyville, IN

Pyatt Builders

From $287,500

3 Br | 2.5 Ba | 2 Gr | 1,928 sq ft

Simplicity 1928 | Shelbyville, IN

Pyatt Builders

From $307,500

4 Br | 2.5 Ba | 2 Gr | 2,364 sq ft

Simplicity 2364 | Shelbyville, IN

Pyatt Builders

From $317,500

4 Br | 2.5 Ba | 2 Gr | 2,629 sq ft

Simplicity 2629 | Shelbyville, IN

Pyatt Builders

From $272,500

3 Br | 2 Ba | 2 Gr | 1,531 sq ft

Simplicity 1531 | Shelbyville, IN

Pyatt Builders

From $282,500

3 Br | 2.5 Ba | 2 Gr | 1,796 sq ft

Simplicity 1796 | Shelbyville, IN

Pyatt Builders

From $307,500

4 Br | 2.5 Ba | 2 Gr | 2,324 sq ft

Simplicity 2324 | Shelbyville, IN

Pyatt Builders

From $275,000

3 Br | 2.5 Ba | 2 Gr | 1,544 sq ft

Simplicity 1544 | Shelbyville, IN

Pyatt Builders

From $297,500

3 Br | 2.5 Ba | 2 Gr | 2,115 sq ft

Simplicity 2115 | Shelbyville, IN

Pyatt Builders

From $327,500

4 Br | 2.5 Ba | 2 Gr | 2,868 sq ft

Simplicity 2868 | Shelbyville, IN

Pyatt Builders

From $287,500

3 Br | 2.5 Ba | 2 Gr | 1,953 sq ft

Simplicity 1953 | Shelbyville, IN

Pyatt Builders

From $282,500

3 Br | 2.5 Ba | 2 Gr | 1,790 sq ft

Simplicity 1790 | Shelbyville, IN

Pyatt Builders

From $260,000

2 Br | 2 Ba | 2 Gr | 1,350 sq ft

Simplicity 1350 | Shelbyville, IN

Pyatt Builders

From $275,000

3 Br | 2.5 Ba | 2 Gr | 1,594 sq ft

Simplicity 1594 | Shelbyville, IN

Pyatt Builders

Static Map Image

Market Snapshot

Newest Home Developments in Shelbyville

CommunityPriced From
Twelve Oaks$ 260,000
Bear Run$ 275,990
Clearview$ 284,995

Top Home Builders in Shelbyville

BuilderHomesAverage Price
D.R. Horton441$339,165
Pyatt Builders285$302,247
M/I Homes174$329,304
Silverthorne Homes74$323,120

Things to Do in Shelbyville

Shelbyville welcomes you with the slogan “Shelbyville Pride in Progress” to highlight how proud they are to combine growth in recreation, industry, and technology while maintaining the charm of a friendly small town. Residents also have easy access to Indianapolis just 26 miles away while enjoying the peace of living with low crime rates as confirmed by a 2016 study conducted by BackgroundChekcs.org, which ranked it as the 4th safest town among 25 in Indiana.

As a family focused community, the city has developed an incredible amount of recreational opportunities for family members of all ages. Many parks go beyond the traditional attractions of trails, playgrounds, or soccer and basketball courts to include new attractions such as the “KID CONNECTION” in Kennedy Park, which offers a play area with universal access for children with all kind of abilities and ages. In Blue River Memorial Park the young and children get a lot of fun in the “Splash Pad”. The variety of programs keeps everyone busy during the year. Among them, “Hook a Kid on Golf” take the youngest to Shelbyville golf lover´s paradise Bear Chase Golf Club to introduce them to the skills and techniques of golf. Adults and seniors have the Indiana Grand Racing & Casino with the hottest slots, e-table games, and live music events. The casino also provides jobs and revenues from its taxes have been wisely used to improve schools and public services.

Everything You Need to Know About New Homes in Shelbyville

Shelbyville is a great place for people who want to invest in living in a community with new homes for sale homes. 61 new home communities offer 743 available new homes, ready to build, starting at just $232,995. With spacious floorplans featuring up to 6 bedrooms in 4,069 square feet, home shoppers can live comfortably in their new home.

Buy Your New Home Today!

Shelbyville is ready to make you part of its bright future with exciting possibilities. With NewHomeSource you can easily access the best properties available in the zone to make sure you get the best chance to relocate here. You can take your time to customize ready to build homes or relocate soon with move in ready options with the best styles and designs.

There are only 743 new construction homes in Shelbyville. For more options to choose from, try expanding your search to include all Indianapolis area new construction homes. You might also consider home types across the Indianapolis area that are in good supply incuding new construction luxury homes, new townhomes in Indianapolis, or 55 plus new construction homes in Indianapolis.

Market Overview: New Construction in Shelbyville, IN

Here is a quick overview of housing developments in Shelbyville, as well as the new construction outlook for new build homes in Shelbyville:

CityShelbyville
StateIndiana
Metro AreaIndianapolis
Subdivisions61
Quick Move in Homes243
Homes Under Construction214
Starting Price$232,995
Average Price$306,563
Price Per Square Foot$138
Home Builders10
Builders in Shelbyville
  • Pyatt Builders
  • Silverthorne Homes
  • M/I Homes

Customizable Options in Shelbyville

Floor Plans Available448
Bedroom Count2 to 6
Bathroom Count2 to 4
Square Footage Range1,228 to 4,069 sq/ft.