New Jersey, home to the famous Jersey Shore, is a small state with a big personality. Known as the Garden State, New Jersey is the birthplace of a number of firsts, including being where the first submarine was built, the first pro baseball and basketball games were played and the first drive-in movie theater was opened.
But besides its colorful history, New Jersey also offers its residents a safe place to call home, as evidenced by its ranking as the fourth safest state in America according to recent FBI data. If you’re looking to move to a secure area full of historic charm, the Garden State might be just for you. Check out our list of the top 10 safest cities in New Jersey, and find the best New Jersey cities for retirees.
The "Safest Cities" series evaluates and ranks the safest cities in each U.S. state using crime data from the FBI and state databases. Our analysis considers population size, violent and nonviolent crime rates, the most common crime, and comparisons to national and state averages. Violent crimes include homicide, assault, robbery, and sexual assault, while nonviolent crimes encompass burglary, theft, and vehicle-related offenses. Each city’s safety score is weighted, emphasizing violent crimes. Data inconsistencies and reporting variations are acknowledged as limitations. This analysis aims to help individuals and families make informed decisions about where to live.
Top 10 Safest Cities in New Jersey
1. New Hanover
Population: 8,123
Number of Violent Crimes: 1
Number of Nonviolent Crimes: 0
Most Common Crime: not applicable
New Hanover is located in Burlington County. This small, rural town is just minutes from Fort Dix and McGuire Air Force Base and under an hour’s drive to larger cities like Trenton and Philadelphia. New Hanover has been crowned the safest city in New Jersey on account of its ultra-low violent crime rate. The township also boasts one of the lowest property crime rates in the Garden State. If the peaceful life is what you’re after, look no further than New Hanover.
Along with being super safe, the area comes with a dense suburban atmosphere that makes it a great spot for families. Proximity to the Joint Base McGuire-Dix-Lakehurst ensures an active presence of military families and a close-knit, supportive community spirit. For healthcare, residents have access to nearby facilities like Deborah Heart and Lung Center in Browns Mills and Virtua Health hospitals in the surrounding area, ensuring good quality care within a short drive.
Education is served through the North Hanover Township School District for younger grades, and high school students often attend Northern Burlington Regional High School. Burlington County College and nearby institutions in Trenton and Philadelphia provide further education options.
New Hanover’s charm lies in its laid-back pace and wide-open spaces—think farmland, old-growth forests, and quiet communities where everyone waves hello.
2. Matawan
Population: 8,864
Number of Violent Crimes: 0
Number of Nonviolent Crimes: 1
Most Common Crime: Property
Just a few miles from the famous Jersey Shore lies Matawan. Matawan sits in Monmouth County, about midway between New York City and the Jersey Shore, giving it a prime spot for anyone wanting a bit of both worlds. This small town, often nicknamed “The Gateway to the Shore,” is known for its rich history and proximity to the coastline.
Matawan has an almost cinematic quality, with historic Victorian homes, scenic lakes, and tree-lined streets, making it both a commuter’s delight and a quiet refuge. Access to major highways and a local NJ Transit train station means you’re only a quick ride from New York City or the beach, making it a town for people who value convenience with character.
Safety is a strong point for Matawan, and the town prides itself on a low crime rate, making it attractive to families and retirees. Local parks, like Lake Lefferts and Cheesequake State Park, offer outdoor recreation, from boating and fishing to hiking and picnicking. Cheesequake, in particular, is a standout, with diverse ecosystems and trails that attract nature lovers from across the region.
Healthcare options in the area include Raritan Bay Medical Center in Old Bridge and Bayshore Medical Center in Holmdel, offering quality services close to home. Matawan is part of the Matawan-Aberdeen Regional School District, known for its dedication to academic excellence, and several nearby colleges, including Rutgers University and Monmouth University, expand the local education landscape.
Matawan’s blend of history, natural beauty, and proximity to New York makes it an ideal spot for anyone seeking a slower pace without straying too far from the action.
3. Chesterfield
Population: 9,330
Number of Violent Crimes: 3
Number of Nonviolent Crimes: 6
Most Common Crime: Property and Larceny
Chesterfield is a picturesque community in Burlington County, known for its rural landscapes, agricultural roots, and quaint charm. Located about halfway between Trenton and Philadelphia, Chesterfield combines a small-town feel with easy access to larger city conveniences. Chesterfield also features quality public schools, which, when combined with its low crime rate, makes it a prime choice for families.
What sets Chesterfield apart is its commitment to preserving farmland and open spaces. This is a town where fields stretch as far as the eye can see, and farms, farmers’ markets, and historic buildings are central to the local lifestyle. The community is tight-knit and focused on family-oriented living, with a strong sense of safety and a low crime rate. Parks and green spaces, like the historic Crosswicks Creek, provide ample opportunities for outdoor activities, from hiking to fishing.
Healthcare needs are covered by nearby hospitals in Trenton and Mount Holly, including Capital Health and Virtua Health facilities. Chesterfield’s local schools are part of the Northern Burlington County Regional School District, known for solid academic programs and extracurricular activities that cater to students of all interests.
Chesterfield’s blend of rural charm, safety, and proximity to both Philadelphia and New York make it an ideal choice when you are looking for a peaceful, community-centered environment in New Jersey.
4. Tewksbury
Population: 5,887
Number of Violent Crimes: 0
Number of Nonviolent Crimes: 12
Most Common Crime: Property and Larceny
Tewksbury is a charming township located within the New York Metropolitan Area. While the real estate here is on the more expensive side, the great schools and tranquil ambience justify the higher price tag. Tewksbury offers a taste of rural beauty in Hunterdon County, known for rolling hills, historic homes, and a lifestyle that’s equal parts country charm and sophisticated taste. Located an hour from New York City and just under that from Philadelphia, it’s well-positioned for those looking for an escape from the city grind.
Tewksbury also has incredible scenery, perfect for those who are enchanted by the countryside. Tewksbury’s character is rooted in its pastoral landscapes, with well-preserved historic villages like Oldwick and a proud farming heritage that residents are quick to celebrate. The township offers all kinds of outdoor recreational experiences, including area golf courses and the annual Tewksbury Harvest Festival.
With its low crime rate and tight-knit community, safety is a highlight in Tewksbury. The local police department and community programs keep residents feeling secure, and the town fosters a close connection among neighbors. Hunterdon Medical Center in Flemington and nearby healthcare options in Morristown offer high-quality medical care within a reasonable distance. The Tewksbury Township Schools serve younger students, while Voorhees High School in the North Hunterdon-Voorhees Regional High School District provides a strong secondary education.
Families are drawn here for the blend of peace and accessibility, while retirees and professionals alike enjoy the balance of rural life with city proximity.
5. Mendham
Population: 5,989
Number of Violent Crimes: 0
Number of Nonviolent Crimes: 20
Most Common Crime: Property and Larceny
If you’re searching for a secure and scenic place to call home, Mendham might be just the spot for you. While homes in this township come at a higher price, the serenity and historic charm that define the area make the money well worth it.
Mendham, nestled in Morris County, combines a colonial-era charm with affluent modern living. Known for its winding roads, historic landmarks, and stone-walled estates, it’s a place where history meets wealth and beauty in seamless harmony. Located roughly an hour from Manhattan, Mendham provides both the quiet of a small town and the convenience of quick access to New York City.
Safety is a strong point, and the town’s low crime rate adds to its appeal as a family-friendly community. The nearby Morristown Medical Center provides high-quality healthcare options, and the Mendham Borough and Mendham Township school districts are highly regarded, with West Morris Mendham High School offering a rigorous academic program.
It’s sometimes referred to as “Horse Country” thanks to its numerous equestrian properties and riding trails that appeal to horse lovers. Mendham’s parks, like Schiff Nature Preserve and India Brook Park, provide serene spots for hiking and outdoor enjoyment. For a taste of colonial New Jersey, visit Mendham’s famed Black Horse Tavern & Pub.
With its stately homes, vibrant community events, and access to top schools and healthcare, Mendham has a classic appeal that continues to draw potential residents looking to escape to a higher quality of life.
6. North Caldwell
Population: 6,574
Number of Violent Crimes: 5
Number of Nonviolent Crimes: 22
Most Common Crime: Property and Larceny
North Caldwell, New Jersey, located in Essex County, is a scenic suburb with tree-lined streets, rolling hills, and a reputation for safety and exclusivity. Just a half-hour from New York City, North Caldwell is one of the more affluent communities in the area, drawing those looking for an upscale suburban lifestyle with easy access to the city. Known as one of the “Essex Fells” communities, North Caldwell has a small-town feel with all the perks of nearby metropolitan life.
With a notably low crime rate, North Caldwell is a safe haven for families. Nearby hospitals, including Saint Barnabas Medical Center in Livingston, provide excellent healthcare options. North Caldwell schools are part of the West Essex Regional School District, known for strong academics, making it popular with families.
The community is close to several parks and trails, including the beautiful Hilltop Reservation and Grover Cleveland Park. As for recreation, North Caldwell is home to the picturesque Green Brook Country Club.
This suburb’s charm lies in its quiet, upscale feel, safety, and close community ties, making it an appealing choice for professionals and families alike.
7. Montvale
Population: 9,361
Number of Violent Crimes: 6
Number of Nonviolent Crimes: 77
Most Common Crime: Property and Larceny
At the border of New Jersey and New York lies the safe city of Montvale. This suburban area, like many others on this list, has no lack of entertainment in the surrounding area with multiple golf courses, shopping centers and even nearby New York City. If you’re looking for a family-friendly spot with a glowing reputation, Montvale is the way to go.
This town, often associated with nearby “Pascack Valley” communities, offers beautiful residential neighborhoods, well-regarded schools, and top-notch shopping and dining. With the perk of being a quick commute to Manhattan via major highways and train lines, Montvale is ideal for professionals who want suburban space and city access.
Montvale has a low crime rate, and with excellent healthcare facilities nearby, including Hackensack University Medical Center and Valley Hospital in Ridgewood, residents feel well-supported. Montvale schools are part of the Pascack Valley Regional High School District, which has a reputation for academic rigor and strong extracurriculars.
Montvale has a blend of parks, including Chestnut Ridge Park, for family-friendly outdoor fun, while nearby entertainment and shopping hubs keep things interesting for residents. Montvale is full of welcoming surprises and amenities.
With its location, strong schools, and balance of urban and suburban living, Montvale is a well-rounded choice for potential New Jersey residents.
8. Norwood
Population: 5,729
Number of Violent Crimes: 1
Number of Nonviolent Crimes: 19
Most Common Crime: Property and Larceny
Next up is Norwood, located at the upper northeastern edge of New Jersey near the Hudson River. Norwood, in Bergen County, is a small, cozy town known for its family-friendly neighborhoods and close-knit community atmosphere. With easy access to New York City, it’s an attractive place for those looking to balance suburban life with city proximity. Norwood’s residential charm is enhanced by its well-regarded schools and a strong sense of local pride.
Norwood’s local parks, like Kennedy Field and Norwood Memorial Park, provide ample green space. Nature lovers will be thrilled with the nearby Palisades Interstate Park, area country clubs and more. Plus, the Big Apple itself is less than an hour away!
Safety is a priority in Norwood, and the community enjoys a low crime rate and active neighborhood watch programs. The town’s healthcare needs are met by nearby hospitals, such as Englewood Health and Hackensack University Medical Center. Norwood Public School and Northern Valley Regional High School at Old Tappan serve the area, providing solid educational options.
The town’s mix of small-town comfort and access to urban amenities makes it a great place to call home.
9. Chester
Population: 1,678
Number of Violent Crimes: 0
Number of Nonviolent Crimes: 22
Most Common Crime: Property and Larceny
If you’re on the hunt for small town charm and lots of outdoor activities, Chester is an option that surely fits the bill. The township is considered one of the highest-income communities in all of New Jersey, meaning real estate in the area is on the pricier side. However, the highly rated schools and sense of security are worth every penny for families.
Chester is a charming town in Morris County with a rich agricultural heritage and a thriving main street. Known for its picturesque countryside, Chester is surrounded by farms, orchards, and seasonal markets that make it a popular destination for day-trippers and residents alike. The town is about an hour from New York City, blending rural appeal with accessibility to urban areas.
Safety is a point of pride in Chester, and the town’s low crime rate and supportive community programs make it a family-friendly location. Morristown Medical Center and Hunterdon Medical Center are nearby for healthcare needs, ensuring quality care close to home. Chester’s schools are part of the West Morris Regional High School District, known for academic excellence and a wide range of extracurricular activities.
Downtown Chester’s shops, eateries, and seasonal festivals provide local entertainment, while nearby trails and parks, such as Hacklebarney State Park, offer outdoor activities. This small town packs a punch. It is a lovely option for families and retirees looking for a peaceful, picturesque place to call home.
10. Upper Saddle River
Population: 8,480
Number of Violent Crimes: 1
Number of Nonviolent Crimes: 30
Most Common Crime: Property and Larceny
Rounding off the list is Upper Saddle River, which lies just under the border dividing New Jersey and New York. This quiet, affluent community located in Bergen County, known for its spacious homes, rolling landscapes, and family-friendly atmosphere. Just 30 miles from Manhattan, Upper Saddle River combines a luxurious suburban lifestyle with the perks of quick city access. Residents here value their privacy and the town’s close-knit vibe, enjoying large lots, mature trees, and beautiful neighborhoods that offer a tranquil retreat from urban life.
Upper Saddle River has a reputation for being very safe, with a low crime rate and active local law enforcement. Healthcare is well-covered with nearby hospitals like Valley Hospital in Ridgewood and Hackensack University Medical Center. The Upper Saddle River Public School District and the Northern Highlands Regional High School serve the area, providing quality education with a focus on both academics and extracurriculars.
Parks like Lions Park and Saddle River County Park give residents ample space to enjoy the outdoors, while the nearby shopping and dining options in Ridgewood and Paramus add to the area’s convenience.
Upper Saddle River is ideal for families and retirees who want a spacious, serene environment with access to great schools, top-notch healthcare, and a manageable commute to the city. Discover rural serenity in Upper Saddle River.
Other New Jersey Resources
Best Suburbs in Middlesex County, New Jersey
Ready to move to Middlesex County? Read our relocation guide
Top 10 State Parks in New Jersey
The Healthiest States to Live In
New Jersey’s 10 Best Counties to Live In
How to Build a House in New Jersey
The Most Affordable Cities in New Jersey
Your Guide to Closing Costs in New Jersey
Katherine West
Katherine West is a writer for NewHomeSource.com and HomLuv.com, where she contributes articles related to home and lifestyle. Her absolute favorite topic to write about is interior design. She is also a former media intern for Builders Digital Experience (BDX). Katherine attends Texas State University in San Marcos, Texas, where she is pursuing a degree in psychology with a minor in mass communications. In her free time, she enjoys creating digital art, reading and anything involving music and film.